Solicitors for Disputes Over Alterations & Improvements to Commercial Property

Disputes over alterations can be an area of contention stemming from the misunderstanding or misinterpretation of the terms of a lease, either on the part of the landlord or the tenant. These disputes can often escalate, becoming disruptive, stressful, and expensive to resolve.

Whether you are a landlord experiencing issues with a tenant who has carried out alterations without permission, breaching the terms of your agreement, or you are a tenant whose landlord is disputing the legality of alterations that you have made; Lupton Fawcett can help.  We have extensive experience of this area of law and we can help you to resolve your dispute as quickly and efficiently as possible.

For expert legal advice on any type of Commercial Property Dispute contact Lupton Fawcett today.

How can Lupton Fawcett help?

When dealing with alteration disputes, it is vital that both landlords and tenants protect their interests by making any agreements properly and legally. We can offer you expert, specialised advice prior to any alterations taking place, with the aim of preventing any future disputes. Where a dispute has already arisen, we can act on your behalf, offering practical solutions and keeping your business needs at the forefront of everything that we do.

Why do alteration disputes arise?

When a tenant takes on a commercial property, the terms of the agreement should be extremely clear so that both parties understand what is and is not permitted. Often, a tenant may want to make changes to a property to accommodate their business needs, and ideally this should be discussed and agreed when the lease is initially drawn up.

A tenant may wish to modernise or to make alterations to a property, which may have implications for the landlord. They may be unwilling to have their property altered, potentially leaving them with a property that may be more difficult to re-let as a result, or costly to undo. Both parties need to be clear about their intentions and to communicate them effectively from the outset.

The role of the lease in alteration disputes

The lease should state whether or not alterations are permitted, and it should be the first place that a tenant looks when considering making any changes. If the subject of alterations is omitted from a lease, then the tenant may be able to make any changes they wish, although this is rare, and it is strongly recommended that the tenant seeks to clarify this ahead of making changes.

It is usually the case that a commercial lease will include some restrictions on alterations. It is unusual that a tenant will be permitted to make any structural alterations, but non-structural changes are often permitted with prior consent. If a tenant applies for permission to make alterations, a landlord has a duty to respond in a prompt and reasonable manner.

Some leases completely prohibit any kind of alteration. Where this is the case a landlord must be extremely cautious if they consent to a request to make an alteration, as this may leave them in breach of covenant, which can be costly to resolve.

Considerations for commercial landlords

As a commercial landlord, if a tenant requests permission to make alterations to your property, there a several factors to consider:

  • Do the proposed changes need further consent, such as planning permission?
  • Is the tenant aware of any other applicable laws, such as adherence to Building Regulations, or fire safety legislation?
  • Will the proposed changes affect the building’s insurance?
  • Will the changes affect rent review provisions? Will the alterations made by the tenant lead to them paying a higher rent, based on the improvement of the property that they have brought about with their alterations?

A Licence for Alterations

A request to make alterations comes with many considerations for both parties and is rarely a straightforward issue. Bearing this in mind, it is wise for both parties to make sure that any changes are reflected in the lease so that they both have their interests legally protected. This can be done either by drawing up a new lease, or by renewing the existing lease with the details of the alterations included. Any alterations carried out, or consent given by the landlord should be recorded in a Licence for Alterations.

A Licence for Alterations is important to a tenant to make sure that they comply with the terms of their lease and do not inadvertently cause a breach that could lead to enforcement procedures. It is advisable to ensure that this is in place before any alterations are carried out, as a retrospective application can be problematic for the tenant.

For a landlord, a Licence for Alterations offers any protection they might need to ensure that the property is returned to its previous state, if that is what they wish. A lease will often include a reinstatement clause, obligating the tenant to remove any fittings installed during their occupation, but it is important that the landlord has a full understanding of any work that has been carried out.

Contact us

Lupton Fawcett are a leading personal and commercial law firm in Yorkshire with well-established offices of highly experienced solicitors in LeedsSheffield and York.

We provide a personalised service, with sector specialists and extensive resources to ensure we are giving you the best solutions to your problems.

Our Commercial Property Litigation Solicitors act regularly for clients across the United Kingdom including Bradford, Birmingham, Hull, Leeds, Liverpool, London, Manchester, Sheffield, York and Nottingham.  We can support your needs wherever you live in England, Wales & Northern Ireland.

For a no obligation initial consultation please either call the office or leave your details using the contact form at the top of this page.  We’ll be happy to help.

"Simon Lockley is the top dog in this field. Technically superb and realistic in advising on prospects."

Legal 500 2021

The team is extremely knowledgeable, approachable and technically excellent. It really cares about getting the best results and is a delight to work with.

Legal 500 2019

Lupton Fawcett is a good full-service firm, which provides reliably high-quality advice with a real sense of how to meet commercial clients’ needs with a personal touch.

Legal 500 2019

Hayden's knowledge and understanding of the property industry has been invaluable to my company and the service he provides us is second to none.

Nick Satman, Managing Director

Gateway Homes Uk Limited

Related Blog Posts

Supreme Court decision restricts landlord’s right to terminate lease 2

Capitol Park Leeds Plc v Global Radio Services Ltd (2021)

In the recent case of Capitol Park Leeds plc (“Capitol”) v Global Radio Services Ltd (“Global”) (2021) the Court of Appeal had to determine whether Global

Pencil iconBy Emma Rennison on 28th July 2021

Forfeiture Moratorium Extended for the Fifth Time

Forfeiture Moratorium Extended for the Fifth Time

On 16 June 2021 the government announced its intention to extend the restrictions put in place to protect commercial tenants until 25 March 2022

Pencil iconBy Natasha Wright on 18th June 2021

Supreme Court decision restricts landlord’s right to terminate lease 2

Tenant’s failure to pay rent during the Covid-19 pandemic – what action can a Landlord take?

Landlords are currently unable to forfeit commercial leases as a result of non-payment of rent. This is a temporary ban which has been implemented as

Pencil iconBy Thomas Parkes on 19th May 2021

Adverse Possession

What can a landlord do when a commercial tenant is not paying rent?

The ongoing Covid-19 pandemic is having a detrimental effect on both commercial landlords and commercial tenants alike. What are the options open to a landlord?

Pencil iconBy Claire Moss on 19th November 2020

Adam 1

Adam Wilkinson on Commercial Property

Adam Wilkinson, Partner in our Commercial Property department, talks all things Commercial Property

Pencil iconBy Adam Wilkinson on 5th November 2020

Adverse Possession

New Code of Practice for Commercial Property Relationships

A new Code of Practice has been developed with leaders from retail, hospitality and property sectors to provide clarity for businesses when discussing rental payments

Pencil iconBy Claire Moss on 13th July 2020

Adverse Possession

Is your Landlord trying to make you pay for Property improvements or upgrades?

If you are a tenant of commercial premises, almost certainly your lease will contain obligations that you have to keep the premises you occupy in

Pencil iconBy Claire Moss on 21st November 2019

Understanding Minimum Energy Efficiency Standards 1

Understanding Minimum Energy Efficiency Standards

We are living in more of an eco-friendly society compared to that of previous generations. So it is only natural that legislation is coming into

Pencil iconBy Lupton Fawcett on 25th March 2019

Adverse Possession

Things for tenants to remember over the Christmas Period

The retail and hospitality sectors have their business trading period of the year over the Christmas period but it is important not to overlook your

Pencil iconBy Hayden Glynn on 3rd December 2018

Adverse Possession

Do I need Planning Permission for that?

Even an extension or new building, such as a conservatory, garage or home office, built within the grounds of your property may not need planning

Pencil iconBy Lupton Fawcett on 25th October 2018

Adverse Possession

The Cost of Fire Safety

On 14 August 2018, the government’s consultation on whether to ban the use of combustible cladding in high-rise residential buildings closed.

Pencil iconBy Claire Moss on 17th September 2018

No competition abuse by refusal to supply spare parts to repairers

Preparing for changes to HMO Licensing

Mandatory licensing will no longer be limited to certain HMOs that are three or more storeys high, but will also include buildings with one or

Pencil iconBy Jeremy Scott on 24th August 2018

Get In Touch Today!

Get In Touch Today!

Please complete this form to make an enquiry and we will get back to you as soon as we can.

Remember you can still call us on 0333 323 5292 or email us at law@luptonfawcett.law

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.